Painful Quandary

Enchantment

Painful Quandary

Name: Painful Quandary
Brand: Magic: The Gathering
SKU: PRM-105716

Enchantment

Magic Online Promos (PRM)·#105716·rare·Feb 9, 2025

Card Text

Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.

Card Details

Mana Value: 5
Colors: Black
Color Identity: Black
EDHREC Rank: #1,187

Features

Format Legalities

Duel

Brawl

Penny

Predh

Future

Legacy

Modern

Pauper

Alchemy

Pioneer

Vintage

Historic

Standard

Timeless

Commander

Gladiator

Oldschool

Premodern

Oathbreaker

Standardbrawl

Paupercommander

Legal

Not Legal

Banned

Restricted

Market Prices

USD

—

USD Foil

—

EUR

—

EUR Foil

—

Prices from TCGPlayer and Cardmarket

Price History (30d)

All Printings (33)

Set	#	Rarity	Lang	Artist	Price	Foil
Magic Online Promos (PRM)	#105716	rare	en	David Palumbo	—	—
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	en	David Palumbo	$2.16	$2.45
Foundations Promos (PFDN)	#179s	rare	en	David Palumbo	—	$2.12
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#331	rare	en	David Palumbo	$3.25	$4.13
The Brothers' War Promos (PBRO)	#111s	rare	en	David Palumbo	—	$2.68
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	en	David Palumbo	$2.64	$1.89
The Brothers' War Promos (PBRO)	#111p	rare	en	David Palumbo	$2.39	$2.81
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	en	Whit Brachna	$2.05	$12.65
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	de	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	de	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#331	rare	de	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	de	Whit Brachna	—	—
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	es	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	es	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	es	Whit Brachna	—	—
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	fr	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	fr	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#331	rare	fr	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	fr	Whit Brachna	—	—
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	it	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	it	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	it	Whit Brachna	—	—
Foundations (FDN)	#179	rare	ja	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#331	rare	ja	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	ja	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	ja	Whit Brachna	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	pt	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	pt	Whit Brachna	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	ru	Whit Brachna	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#111	rare	zhs	David Palumbo	—	—
The Brothers' War (BRO)	#331	rare	zhs	David Palumbo	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	zhs	Whit Brachna	—	—
Scars of Mirrodin (SOM)	#73	rare	zht	Whit Brachna	—	—